Home
EXECUTED
Ends Oct 4 at 10:46 PM UTC

[EP4.2][Executable] Fund the Endowment (second tranche)


By
Skip to Votes

Abstract

This proposal outlines the allocation of the second tranche, comprising 16,000 ETH, from the ENS DAO to the ENS Endowment. Additionally, it introduces minor adjustments to the existing permissions preset for maintenance purposes.

Motivation

In March 2023, the ENS Endowment was formally established following the joint proposal by karpatkey and @steakhouse, after the successful execution of E.P 3.4 - Fund the Endowment (first tranche). The community had expressed a preference for a phased funding approach, leading to the decision to allocate the funds in two equal tranches over a six-month interval. As we reach this pivotal milestone, this proposal seeks community approval for the second tranche.

Endowment Update

Based on the most recent monthly report detailing the Endowment’s performance for August 2023, the Endowment has achieved:

  • $28.03 M of ncAUM (non-custodial assets under management)
  • 100% of capital utilisation
  • An APY (annual percentage yield) of 4.1%
  • Monthly farming results of $93,841

A comprehensive review post detailing our collaborative efforts with the ENS DAO has been recently shared on the forum. We encourage community members to consult this post for insights into our achievements and ongoing initiatives.

Cumulative Revenues

In the 182 days since the Endowment was established, 173 ETH have been accrued through ETH-neutral strategies and $136,764 in stablecoin revenues via USD-neutral strategies. Operational reports were initially shared on a weekly basis and later transitioned to monthly updates, all of which were made available on the forum for community review.

The Endowment's phased initiation should also be taken into account when interpreting these results. Full capital utilisation was only achieved 49 days after the Endowment's inception, following the completion of the earned ETH-to-stablecoin tranche swaps. This staggered approach had a discernible impact on the reported financial metrics.

Taking into consideration the revenue generated during the most recent four months—after reaching 100% capital utilisation—the projected annual revenues at the current Endowment’s size stand at 367 ETH from ETH-neutral strategies and an equivalent of $351,654 in stablecoins from USD-neutral strategies. This results in a projected Annual Percentage Rate (APR) of approximately 3.4%.

Specification

Fund Transfer

Transfer 16,000 ETH to the Endowment (0x4F2083f5fBede34C2714aFfb3105539775f7FE64).

Permissions preset adjustments

In line with our commitment to streamline governance and reduce the frequency of voting events for the community, we propose targeted adjustments to the existing permissions preset within this proposal. Specifically, we are requesting three key changes:

  • Whitelisting the updated wstETH-WETH Pool and Gauge: As part of our ongoing optimization, we propose to whitelist the updated wstETH-WETH pool on Balancer and its corresponding gauge on Aura.
  • Revoking Permissions for Aura's bb-a-usd Pool: In light of the recent vulnerability disclosed by Balancer on August 24, 2023, we recommend revoking all permissions associated with potentially compromised pools. It's important to note that the Endowment had no exposure to these compromised pools at the time the vulnerability was made public.
  • Whitelisting the delegatecall function on Cow Swap: A minor bug was found in the existing preset configuration. Specifically, the signOrder function within Cow Swap's order signer contract is designed to be executed solely via a delegate call, a capability not currently supported by the preset. This oversight not only hindered functionality but also revealed a flaw in the SDK preset testing framework. The issue has been swiftly addressed and rectified in a recent commit to the codebase.

As is customary, we are presenting an updated version of the "Preset permissions - ENS Endowment'' document. This document comprehensively lists all permissions granted to karpatkey, with newly requested permissions highlighted in green and any revocations marked in red.

We are also sharing the payload to apply the proposed changes for your review. We strongly encourage community members with the required technical expertise to scrutinise the content and share their invaluable feedback.

Transactions

All transactions can be found in the following payload.

Votes
Quorum progress: 129.11%
For votes: 1.29M
Against votes: 513.45K
0x9831...67440x9831...6744voted against
174.06K
0x5bfc...83900x5bfc...8390voted against
167.57K
Rationale posted to forum: https://discuss.ens.domains/t/4-2-executable-fund-the-endowment-second-tranche/17743/4?u=james
0xb8c2...67d50xb8c2...67d5voted for
160.53K
Karpatkey has been a good steward of our funds so far. We should expand the endowment as previously agreed.
0xed11...bb040xed11...bb04voted for
147.54K
0x809f...f68e0x809f...f68evoted for
147.44K
0x2b88...7d120x2b88...7d12voted for
131.19K
0x89ed...aedc0x89ed...aedcvoted for
118.91K
I'm in general in support of the long-term management of the DAO funds to ensure a healthy future for funding the project as a whole; my only concern has been the current emphasis on Lido. The management team has socially agreed to take the DAO's feedback to heart when deciding the investment direction, which has overwhelmingly been to reduce the stake in Lido, so I consider my concerns addressed.
0x76a6...bbb80x76a6...bbb8voted for
106.13K
0x8393...07800x8393...0780voted for
103.07K
0x399e...55410x399e...5541voted against
96.08K
Endowing funds to Karpatkey presents a significant risk to the Ethereum network as they rely heavily on Lido for staking services. See further comments here: https://discuss.ens.domains/t/4-2-executable-fund-the-endowment-second-tranche/17743/5
0x54be...7ab60x54be...7ab6voted for
95.21K
0xbdb4...f1dc0xbdb4...f1dcvoted against
62.75K
0x5346...42cf0x5346...42cfvoted for
56.77K
0x48db...d85d0x48db...d85dvoted for
48.27K
0x1d54...63590x1d54...6359voted for
44.21K
0xbce3...776f0xbce3...776fvoted for
42.5K
0x4e67...a83b0x4e67...a83bvoted for
39.4K
0xd5d1...cf2c0xd5d1...cf2cvoted for
21.23K
0x3335...81e10x3335...81e1voted against
9.36K
0x29a8...de700x29a8...de70voted for
6.88K
0x61a0...cb7b0x61a0...cb7bvoted for
5.07K
0x0291...1b630x0291...1b63voted for
4.72K
0xe52c...d7260xe52c...d726voted for
2.89K
I shared my thoughts and reasoning here: https://discuss.ens.domains/t/4-2-executable-fund-the-endowment-second-tranche/17743/19
0xf342...33290xf342...3329voted for
2.1K
0x30c7...c7020x30c7...c702voted for
1.82K
0xa786...77c60xa786...77c6voted against
1.7K
Two things I consider true at the same time: 1. I believe Karpatkey does a great job at what they do 2. I disagree our approach to treasury management. Currently, I think the ideal approach is holding ETH, performing a quarterly swap to USDC to maintain ~2 years runway, and at most, hold some portion of ETH in LSTs
0xe391...b4060xe391...b406voted for
1.14K
This has been in the works/pre-planned for a while (everything is on the forum under the Treasury Management tag), and kudos to Karpatkey for being a trusted steward of the ENS Endowment thus far.
0xc605...2beb0xc605...2bebvoted for
1.1K
0x5a38...06150x5a38...0615voted for
825
0xd1b6...47430xd1b6...4743voted against
705
0x9be6...78890x9be6...7889voted for
453
0x2273...35f70x2273...35f7abstained
418
Voting abstain to get more people voting so results are more balanced and debated. 384.eth
0xe530...51f90xe530...51f9voted against
300
0xe626...51400xe626...5140voted for
299
0x035e...17d30x035e...17d3voted for
287
0xbd53...d9dd0xbd53...d9ddvoted against
250
0xebaa...ab800xebaa...ab80voted against
152
0x6f9b...8a1d0x6f9b...8a1dvoted against
141
0x168f...74000x168f...7400voted against
131
0xe490...bc340xe490...bc34voted against
106
0xca7a...dc960xca7a...dc96voted for
102
0xc48b...75b60xc48b...75b6voted against
97
0xefc9...80810xefc9...8081voted for
83
0x8d0d...9a9a0x8d0d...9a9avoted for
74
0x5a72...509b0x5a72...509babstained
68
0x2c66...1b6a0x2c66...1b6avoted for
42
0x71e2...0d9a0x71e2...0d9avoted against
31
0x9cea...ee3c0x9cea...ee3cvoted for
21
0xabb2...60560xabb2...6056voted for
15
0xb89b...ecb30xb89b...ecb3voted for
14
0x111a...d3c30x111a...d3c3voted for
13
0x7449...9e700x7449...9e70voted for
12
0x70df...18890x70df...1889voted for
12
0xe06f...857d0xe06f...857dvoted for
11
0x33dd...90e50x33dd...90e5voted for
11
0x7824...ad270x7824...ad27voted for
10
0x8da4...81e40x8da4...81e4voted for
10
0x8bc8...72760x8bc8...7276voted for
10
0x1768...06130x1768...0613voted for
10
0x4545...46e60x4545...46e6voted for
10
0x1824...ce630x1824...ce63voted for
10
0xfb40...72500xfb40...7250voted against
10
0x11ce...f3c70x11ce...f3c7voted for
7
0x1706...14ac0x1706...14acvoted for
6
0x82f0...93c10x82f0...93c1voted for
4
1
0xc52e...5a530xc52e...5a53voted for
4
0x7334...4be50x7334...4be5voted for
3
0xd90e...5d160xd90e...5d16voted for
3
0x48c1...13790x48c1...1379voted for
3
0x8a9a...9f4e0x8a9a...9f4evoted for
3
0xc34a...68c20xc34a...68c2voted for
3
0x66cb...15960x66cb...1596voted for
3
0x1297...4e4f0x1297...4e4fvoted for
3
0x3996...4e820x3996...4e82voted for
2
0x9549...a2d80x9549...a2d8voted for
2
0x0151...c3b90x0151...c3b9voted for
2
0xc15b...844f0xc15b...844fvoted for
2
0x71a2...e1ea0x71a2...e1eavoted for
2
0x37f0...a0a70x37f0...a0a7voted for
2
0x8b11...0c6d0x8b11...0c6dvoted for
2
0x56e0...98f10x56e0...98f1voted for
2
0x403c...60ab0x403c...60abvoted for
2
0xe989...08fa0xe989...08favoted for
2
0x7c88...fb0f0x7c88...fb0fvoted for
2
0x60fd...3a180x60fd...3a18voted for
2
0x7bf4...ddd00x7bf4...ddd0voted for
2
0xee58...48050xee58...4805voted for
1
0x9e4d...96360x9e4d...9636voted for
1
0x7d64...23de0x7d64...23devoted for
1
0xa87b...57530xa87b...5753voted for
1
0x46db...d83c0x46db...d83cvoted for
1
0x3486...e8de0x3486...e8devoted for
1
0x43b9...fabc0x43b9...fabcvoted for
1
good
0x1282...54bd0x1282...54bdvoted for
1
0x80bc...1d580x80bc...1d58voted for
1
0x0270...eada0x0270...eadavoted for
1
0xa0f9...0fc30xa0f9...0fc3voted for
1
0x7dc7...9ddb0x7dc7...9ddbvoted for
1
0x2f2f...f78a0x2f2f...f78avoted for
1
0x1656...1b750x1656...1b75voted for
1
0xabfd...ba270xabfd...ba27voted for
1
0x390b...e9040x390b...e904voted for
1
0x240d...4e0d0x240d...4e0dvoted for
1
0x224d...9cb40x224d...9cb4voted for
1
0x1dc3...0ab90x1dc3...0ab9voted for
1
0x0481...a2050x0481...a205voted for
1
0xa371...76810xa371...7681voted for
1
0xdcd7...bddb0xdcd7...bddbvoted for
1
0x1f75...42d80x1f75...42d8voted for
1
0x11c5...624e0x11c5...624evoted for
1
0x5b65...c0f10x5b65...c0f1voted for
1
0x0120...b4aa0x0120...b4aavoted for
1
0x0c33...86580x0c33...8658voted for
1
0x1378...afe80x1378...afe8voted for
1
0x2b5f...aaac0x2b5f...aaacvoted for
1
0x6382...d9e80x6382...d9e8voted for
1
0xffb4...c1980xffb4...c198voted for
1
0xe176...d27d0xe176...d27dvoted for
1
0x3d21...f0850x3d21...f085voted for
1
0xcb3c...c54c0xcb3c...c54cvoted for
1
0x6433...44d00x6433...44d0voted for
1
0xf54c...87f60xf54c...87f6voted for
1
0xf91d...eda90xf91d...eda9voted for
1
0x8442...cf920x8442...cf92voted for
1
0xe36c...f3bd0xe36c...f3bdvoted for
1
0x1f2e...9bfa0x1f2e...9bfavoted for
1
0x6dae...5bf20x6dae...5bf2voted for
1
0x8e1f...b5790x8e1f...b579voted for
1
0x5644...9d8c0x5644...9d8cvoted for
1
0x289c...73160x289c...7316voted for
1
0x9b08...674b0x9b08...674bvoted for
1
0xbe62...f43a0xbe62...f43avoted for
1
0x4321...8db60x4321...8db6voted for
1
0xddc5...366f0xddc5...366fvoted for
1
0xa4e1...8c5d0xa4e1...8c5dvoted for
1
0xa340...79280xa340...7928voted for
1
0xda6e...62a60xda6e...62a6voted for
1
0x6162...073b0x6162...073bvoted for
1
0xcdaa...f2e50xcdaa...f2e5voted for
1
0x4e95...62d60x4e95...62d6voted for
1
0x0f6f...609d0x0f6f...609dvoted for
1
0x8519...5d7a0x8519...5d7avoted for
1
0x2a22...0c890x2a22...0c89voted for
1
0x6b07...b2570x6b07...b257voted for
1
0x3ce1...798f0x3ce1...798fvoted for
1
0xfbf8...40650xfbf8...4065voted for
1
0x9baf...b5ff0x9baf...b5ffvoted for
1
0x9e9e...dc850x9e9e...dc85voted for
1
0x7028...e35e0x7028...e35evoted for
1
1
0x8852...d89f0x8852...d89fvoted for
1
0x28b8...a1e10x28b8...a1e1voted for
1
0x3b71...99460x3b71...9946voted for
1
0x22ff...cc990x22ff...cc99voted for
1
0x7e3d...90260x7e3d...9026voted for
1
0x3cfa...478e0x3cfa...478evoted for
1
0x2ad3...fa0d0x2ad3...fa0dvoted for
1
0x3760...f7510x3760...f751voted for
1
0xcce9...6a1f0xcce9...6a1fvoted against
1
0x38a0...f31a0x38a0...f31avoted for
1
0xda42...96280xda42...9628voted for
1
0x9d31...e35a0x9d31...e35avoted for
1
0x5d65...1e0f0x5d65...1e0fvoted for
1
0x81ad...d1450x81ad...d145voted for
1
0xc9c6...ecd90xc9c6...ecd9voted for
1
0xbb5e...a3680xbb5e...a368voted for
1
0x733d...f77d0x733d...f77dvoted for
1
0x247b...51270x247b...5127voted for
1
0x6ad3...07f30x6ad3...07f3voted for
1
0xa68b...84280xa68b...8428voted for
1
0x9e3b...5ca80x9e3b...5ca8voted for
1
0xc05d...8e1a0xc05d...8e1avoted for
1
0x50d2...53180x50d2...5318voted for
1
0x3496...126b0x3496...126bvoted for
1
0x28d9...81510x28d9...8151voted for
1
0x9706...104a0x9706...104avoted for
1
0x7b49...7f8a0x7b49...7f8avoted for
1
0xa444...c9090xa444...c909voted for
1
0x6c72...6f4e0x6c72...6f4evoted for
1
0x6f0c...efb20x6f0c...efb2voted against
0
0x0af0...8e160x0af0...8e16voted for
0
0x1102...772d0x1102...772dvoted against
0
0x503d...49640x503d...4964voted for
0
0x1c05...40940x1c05...4094voted for
0
0x2cdb...67680x2cdb...6768voted for
0
0x4d47...3ad90x4d47...3ad9voted for
0
0x227f...f36e0x227f...f36evoted for
0
0xdfd0...bd550xdfd0...bd55voted for
0
0xa212...97590xa212...9759voted for
0
0x48b5...69500x48b5...6950voted for
0
0x7e5f...c40a0x7e5f...c40avoted for
0
0x391b...b8750x391b...b875voted for
0
0x560f...07c30x560f...07c3voted for
0
0x2c86...aaaa0x2c86...aaaavoted for
0
0xc04a...9a110xc04a...9a11voted for
0
0x824d...48350x824d...4835voted for
0
0x8e8a...1bbd0x8e8a...1bbdvoted for
0
4.2
0xfbdb...ee140xfbdb...ee14voted for
0
0xa772...61710xa772...6171voted for
0
0x3d38...4ff40x3d38...4ff4voted for
0
0x6534...d7ef0x6534...d7efvoted for
0
0xc720...c12f0xc720...c12fvoted for
0
0x2c1c...91b80x2c1c...91b8voted against
0
0x78c9...2f250x78c9...2f25voted for
0
0xa186...fc220xa186...fc22voted for
0
0x7d55...b6f60x7d55...b6f6voted for
0
0x31a4...aa2c0x31a4...aa2cvoted for
0
0x5b13...f4c90x5b13...f4c9voted against
0
0xd8de...ae410xd8de...ae41voted for
0
0x4dc2...06d60x4dc2...06d6voted for
0
0x457f...d2380x457f...d238voted for
0
0x76ee...985b0x76ee...985bvoted for
0
0x43e7...35cb0x43e7...35cbvoted for
0
0x400e...0b1c0x400e...0b1cvoted for
0
0xd04c...1b030xd04c...1b03voted for
0
0xaafd...084c0xaafd...084cvoted for
0
0x202a...cbc80x202a...cbc8voted for
0
0xdf39...8ca50xdf39...8ca5voted for
0
0x8b31...35160x8b31...3516voted for
0
0x84ad...b6970x84ad...b697abstained
0
0x3cbd...34020x3cbd...3402voted for
0
0x572a...6ce90x572a...6ce9voted for
0
0x3f96...f18f0x3f96...f18fvoted for
0
0xf565...25160xf565...2516voted for
0
0x9355...ac480x9355...ac48voted for
0
0xc560...4db30xc560...4db3voted for
0
0x0216...1ae20x0216...1ae2voted for
0
0xfc5a...ea410xfc5a...ea41voted for
0
0x8f8a...d1f10x8f8a...d1f1voted for
0
0xaa84...964b0xaa84...964bvoted for
0
0xb9ae...d9b10xb9ae...d9b1voted for
0
0xffb9...54190xffb9...5419voted for
0
0x93b0...65840x93b0...6584voted for
0
0xd4ee...67950xd4ee...6795voted for
0
0x9354...0cc10x9354...0cc1voted for
0
0xb81b...3dbc0xb81b...3dbcvoted for
0
0xf596...306b0xf596...306bvoted for
0
0x274d...73f40x274d...73f4voted against
0
0xf928...3d770xf928...3d77voted for
0
0xfbd0...ac260xfbd0...ac26voted against
0
0xdfbe...e8f80xdfbe...e8f8voted against
0
0xcb0d...7fb30xcb0d...7fb3voted for
0
0x8626...14030x8626...1403voted for
0
0x13a8...aaac0x13a8...aaacvoted for
0
0x6f4a...afd80x6f4a...afd8abstained
0
0x6b5c...a55a0x6b5c...a55avoted for
0
0xfa1f...eaae0xfa1f...eaaevoted for
0